Ectopic Pregnancy and Tubal Rupture After Tubal Reversal
Posted On: Sunday, January 6th, 2008
I recently received an email from a patient who had an ectopic pregnancy subsequent to her tubal reversal. Unfortunately, the pregnancy continued to the point of tubal rupture with the loss of the fallopian tube.
Patient’s History
I was hoping you could help me understand why my ectopic pregnancy was not detected early enough to prevent the loss of my right tube. I need to know this for the future as after my surgery I have only my left tube remaining.
I went to my doctor at approximately 3 weeks pregnant and made sure that they understood the importance of checking for ectopic pregnancy. I gave them a copy of your instructions and told them my goal is to prevent losing my tube if it is ectopic, so I told them to please check and make sure it is not ectopic. They did blood work 3 times and did a vaginal ultrasound at approximately 4 weeks and said everything was normal and the sac was in the uterus, not the tube. They did not check anything again until I spotted Tuesday of this week. I went in Wednesday and they did a vaginal ultrasound and said it was ectopic with a heartbeat and I needed surgery and my tube would have to be removed.
My tube was removed because it was starting to rupture. I never expected that to happen because I took the precautions necessary.
Can you please tell me what normal pregnancy hormone levels are for each week of pregnancy versus ectopic hormone levels?
When is an ectopic visible on ultrasound? Could this have been prevented? Was there anything else that could have been done?
Role of Serum HCG in Early Pregnancy Monitoring
HCG levels alone do not differentiate between uterine and ectopic pregnancy. The HCG levels provide the earliest evidence of whether implantation has occurred successfully (but not where it has occurred) and indicate when ultrasound examination should be able to find a gestation sac if the pregnancy is in the uterine cavity. This occurs when serum HCG reaches 1500-2000 mIU/dL. If serum HCG levels are rising too slowly, or if ultrasound does not find a gestation sac in the uterus when HCG is at the level of 1500-2000, then the pregnancy is not a normal one. It could be outside of the uterus (ectopic) or it could be an abnormal pregnancy in the uterus (blighted ovum).
Role of Transvaginal Ultrasound
A careful transvaginal ultrasound exam can detect a normally developing pregnancy in the uterus very early. It is apparent in this case that the initial ultrasound findings were not interpreted correctly. How could this occur?
An intrauterine gestation sac is a dark oval shaped area of fluid surrounded by a bright white ring or halo (the trophoblastic tissue). Probably in this case there was a small amount of fluid in the uterine cavity that was mistakenly thought to be a gestation sac. This has been described as a “pseudo-sac”. A pseudo-sac does not have the distinct white halo or ring of a true gestation sac.
In a normally developing uterine pregnancy, a follow-up ultrasound exam will show the presence of a yolk sac (the small circle within the gestation sac) within a week of the appearance of the gestation sac. If the initial ultrasound exam had been followed-up with another ultrasound scan, it would have shown that this was not a normal uterine pregnancy.
Comment
There is an increased risk of ectopic pregnancy following tubal reversal surgery. Our follow-up pregnancy statistics show that the risk of ectopic pregnancy remains constant with each pregnancy. In other words, it is the same for a first, second, third, or subsequent pregnancy after tubal reversal surgery. It is important, therefore, to monitor any pregnancy after tubal reversal early and closely.
Recommendations for early pregnancy monitoring are given on our website page entitled I’m Pregnant. Although the recomended tests were performed, the most critical one – the ultrasound exam to document the location of the gestation sac – was interpreted erroneously.
An experienced ultrasonographer should be able to differentiate between a true gestation sac and a pseudo-sac by the presence or absence of the bright halo surrounding the fluid filled sac. If there is any doubt, a repeat ultrasound exam looking for the appearance of a yolk sac should be performed.
Although ectopic pregnancy is not preventable, the complication of tubal rupture always should be. In the absence of clear ultrasound evidence of an intrauterine pregnancy, early treatment with Methotrexate is recommended. It is important to monitor serum HCG levels until the HCG level returns to less than 10 mIU/dL. This will prevent a possible ectopic pregnancy from advancing to the complication of tubal rupture.
January 6th, 2008 at 4:38 pm
It is reassuring for patients who come to Dr. Berger for tubal reversal surgery to know that he puts the patients safety first. Early pregnancy monitoring is very important since there is a risk for ectopic pregnancy after surgery. We like to be informed of each and every pregnancy following surgery. We also like to be informed of the HCG levels until it is been identified where the pregnancy is. We wish that every pregnancy could be a normal one for all pateints but we have seen patients go on to have a healthy uterine pregnancy following an ectopic. There is hope and early pregnancy monitoring is recommended to help women receive treatment as early as possible. Staff members are available 24/7 not only to answer questions about tubal reversal but also to answer questions about early pregnancy monitoring. This is just one way that Dr. Berger goes above and beyond to help his patients.
January 6th, 2008 at 11:31 pm
Patient education is something that Dr. Berger and our entire staff work hard to promote. Nothing is more frustrating or heartbreaking than when we hear that a patient has experienced a tubal pregnancy that has ruptured or required surgery. We hope that the information posted here and on our website – as well as the information given at the time of surgery – will help to reduce or eliminate this situation.
January 7th, 2008 at 11:30 am
This story re-emphasizes the importance of following Dr. Berger’s recommended pregnancy protocol after tubal reversal surgery. It is always so upsetting to hear that a patient has lost both a pregnancy and tube and that the loss of the tube could have been prevented. We always encourage patients to take a copy of the pregnancy protocol with them to their appointments and to make sure that they have an OB-Gyn who will comply with Dr. Berger’s recommendations.
January 7th, 2008 at 2:28 pm
I’d have to agree with both Julia and Rhonda. Nothing is more frustrating or heartbreaking to learn that a patient has experienced a tubal pregnancy. I hope that any patient that has experienced this type of situation, reads this thread and is encouraged by the fact that she can still conceive with one tube!
January 8th, 2008 at 9:44 am
Many of the patients I schedule for reversal surgery have already had an ectopic pregnancy prior to having any surgery on their fallopian tubes! I have talked with a few women that have had all of their children with only one fallopian tube. A lot of people think a women needs both fallopian tubes in order to conceive, but they only need one. It is also encouraging to see most of our patients that have had an ectopic pregnancy go on to have a normal pregnancy and often more than one normal pregnancy.
January 9th, 2008 at 8:23 am
I think this also brings up a good point about patient doctor relationships. It is important for the patient to be well informed and to do so they must ask questions if something is not quite clear. This also takes a doctor who is willing to address any concerns of the patient. That is why I think Chapel Hill Tubal Reversal Center is unique in that it is made up of an entire staff dedicated to patient care and follow-up.
January 10th, 2008 at 12:34 am
Yes, I must agree with all that has been stated here. It is very rare to find one surgeon this committed to his patients and their outcome. The relationship Dr. Berger shares with each and ever patient is sincere and true. He will strive for the best outcome, and he requires that of his staff. No one will give better insihgt about this procedure and how the procedure works. Know that all concerns in relation to the tubal reversal are his top priority. His study and information provided on the website is very helpful, and they are reflections of how much he cares about the outcome of every procedure he does.
April 5th, 2008 at 1:29 pm
[...] most significant risk associated with tubal ligation reversal is the long term risk of having an ectopic pregnancy. This risk is increased from approximately 2% of pregnancies in the general population to [...]
September 18th, 2008 at 5:55 pm
I had a ruptured tubal pregnancy last thanksgiving. I was 3 months along. i had complications from the very beginning. I asked the doctors over and over if there was any chance that it could have been atubal pregnancy. they checked everything and told me everything was fine. Then the day after thanksgiving I got so sick I had to call my mother to come take me to the hospital. we went to the emergency room. They told me that I was misscarring the baby. they gave me a shot and sent me home. My mother was concerned so she took me to her house. There I kept passing out and vomiting. So she called the hospital THey told her that that was from the shot that they gave me. 9 hours later I couldn’t take the pain any more. My mom decided to take me to another hospital. When we arrived they knew exactly what was wrong. They did a vaginal ultrasound and sure enough it was a ruptured tubal pregnancy. I lost 1800cc of blood and they had to remove my left tube. They said that if I wouldn’t have come in I would have died during the night. I think God everyday and pray that I will someday have a baby.
September 18th, 2008 at 6:06 pm
Brittney -
It is disturbing that ruptured tubal pregnancy was allowed to occur, since it is preventable by following the protocol described in this blog article. Serum HCG assays and ultrasound are available in any community and should be used appropriately by doctors caring for women early in pregnancy.
November 7th, 2008 at 10:42 pm
I would like to thank Dr. Bergers office for their support this week after I had a ruptured ectopic pregnancy that lead to the loss of my left tube.
I want to stress the importance to everyone for careful monitoring, I had my AF on Sept 27 and then when it came again on Oct 23, it did not occur to me that I was pregnant. On Nov 1rst, I had extreme pain on the left side, I thought I had a cyst that burst as the pain subsided after 4 or five hours. Nov 2nd I felt okay, tender and bloated, but minor pain. Nov 3rd, in the afternoon, the pain came back, my abdomen started to swell, I went to the ER, had three sonograms and after 7 hours, was told “Congratulations, your blood test shows your pregnant”, and you most likely had a cyst that burst, go home and take it easy and follow up with your OB the next day. By the time I got to my doctor the following night, I could barely sit. My Dr. took a transvaginal ultrasound and immediately confirmed a ruptured left tube and my abdomen was full of blood. I was in surgery within an hour and am so grateful to my doctor.
January 10th, 2009 at 7:22 pm
I Just found out i had a tubal pregnancy and was given the shot, so far i’m ok but bummed tht the baby was in the tubes and not the uterus. I followed Dr. Berger’s instructions for early pregancay mointoring and nothing was ever at 6 weeks a baby cound not be detected in my uterus
January 10th, 2009 at 9:00 pm
Lisa Marie -
Hopefully your HCG level was over 1500-2000 when you had the ultrasound. It has to be higher than that for a vaginal ultrasound exam to see a gestation sac in the uterus. When a gestation sac is not seen and when the serum HCG level is high enough, the possibilities are either a “blighted ovum” that is in the uterus but will miscarry, or a pregnancy outside of the uterus (ectopic pregnancy).
March 31st, 2009 at 2:25 pm
I am in need of advice….I had a tubal pregnancy back in 2004 and was told I lost everything on my left side, so with that I decided to tie my right tube. My Husband and I really regretted doing this, so we decided to go through IVF last October. Sad to say it didn’t take. I then went to another doctor had surgery to see about getting my one tube untied. Come to find out I still have everything on my left side and could have reconstructive surgery and untie the other tube. My insurance paid for the in vitro, but will not pay for this surgery. I fear I will have another ectopic pregnancy and loose a tube and be out thousands of dollars.
April 7th, 2009 at 8:21 am
I had a tubal pregnancy in my right tube about two months ago…I had the injections and the doctors watched my levels for about two weeks. Then all of a sudden when my levels were down to 2000 I had a sharp pain in my right side and started to pass out and get very weak. I was rushed to the hospital to be told that my tube had ruptured and I had 1 litre of blood in the abdominal area….I had emergency surgery and I am still recovering….My question is, could this have been prevented if they had to do the surgery to begin with or even after it took two weeks to get my levels to come down? When is the maximum amount of time doctors wait before they opt to do the surgery to prevent a rupture. I lost my right tube and I also have damage to my left tube. Luckily I have two kids already but would like to have one more….
April 7th, 2009 at 8:38 am
You did have the recommended treatment. The injections of methotrexate generally will treat an ectopic pregnancy but the medication is not always 100% effective. Most people will not have a tubal rupture after methotrexate and will be able to save their tubes. Sounds like your doctors followed our protocol but you were one of the few patients who did not have success with the methotrexate treatment.
April 22nd, 2009 at 3:20 am
I had an abortion a month ago. I might be 3 weeks pregnant right now and I started having lower back pain as well as sharp abdominal pains on the lower left side for about a week now. I’m scarred that it is an ectopic pregnancy but because it is possible for the pregnancy hormone level to be the cause of my positive pregnancy tests and the dr. was not able to see anything in the uterus with the ultrasound, I’m not getting treatment. Is there anything else that can be done besides waiting? Can my tube rupture at this point (3-4 wks)
April 22nd, 2009 at 6:31 am
If the pregnancy is in your tube, rather than having been in your uterus, of course there is the risk of tubal rupture. Your doctor should know whether the pregnancy was in the uterus or not. If you are not confident about the doctor who has been treating you, then you should consult with another ob/gyn physician.
May 28th, 2009 at 9:09 pm
I had a tubal ligation in 2001, my husband and I decided we wanted to have another child and I went through the tubal reversal surgery. We became pregnant four months after having the surgury done. We had a healthy baby boy. Now 2 years later we opted to try for another one. I became pregnant and had an etopic pregnancy that was terminated at 4 weeks, my left tube was removed. What would cause our 1st pregnancy to be normal and this second one to be etopic? I am still left with my right tube but question whether we should even bother trying for another child at this point. My doctor suggested having a dye (HSG) test done prior to me trying to become pregnant. Is this the only method to determine if my tube is open or not and if I am at a higher risk for another etopic pregnancy?
October 14th, 2009 at 8:43 am
My question is: what is the risk of ectopic pregnancy in the general population and what is the risk in women with tubal reversal. Is there anything that can increase or decrease the risk of ectopic pregnancy after tubal reversal?
Thank you very much.
October 14th, 2009 at 8:58 am
Maria
The risk of ectopic pregnancy in the general population is 1-3%.
The risk of ectopic pregnancy among women who have IVF is 1-3%.
The risk of ectopic pregnancy among women with tubal reversal is 10-15%.
There is nothing that can be done to change the risk of ectopic pregnancy. We do recommend monitoring early pregnancies and if they are ectopic then ending the pregnancy with a medication called methotrexate, which can avoid the most serious problems with an ectopic pregnancy.
October 14th, 2009 at 9:12 am
Two more questions:
Does smoking or age increase the risk of ectopic pregnancy?
If an ectopic pregnancy does occur and the fallopian tubes have to be removed is still possible to have IVF?
October 14th, 2009 at 9:24 am
Smoking and age do not increase the risk of ectopic pregnancy. The risk of ectopic pregnancy are increased by anything which changes the natural function of the fallopian tubes, namely pelvic infection and pelvic surgery.
It is possible to have IVF as long as you have a uterus. Even if both fallopian tubes are removed then IVF can be done. IVF does have risks. Anyone considering IVF should read our blog: Tubal Reversal After 40: IVF Risks .
November 17th, 2009 at 7:31 am
My husband and I are trying to have a child and I’ve successfully gotten pregnant. However, at this time we don’t have the health insurance needed for me to get an ultra sound to see how far along I am. We’ll have the insurance in January, but for now I’m taking extra good care of myself for my child’s sake. However, I have a pain and soreness where my right ovary should be and it’s swollen and stiff to the touch. I’m scared it could be an ectopic pregnancy… I can’t have an ultra sound yet to know for sure, and I’m scared. There’s no history of this happening in my family, and I don’t know what to think. I’m not having any other symptoms. Just the soreness and swelling. I also suffer from the occasional painful ovarian cyst, but I don’t know…
November 17th, 2009 at 8:23 am
Kay
Any pregnant woman in the first trimester with severe pelvic pain should be evaluated for an ectopic pregnancy.
February 22nd, 2010 at 4:51 pm
I recently found out I was pregnant. At five weeks/5 days I had an ultrasound. They did not see a sac in the uterus but saw fluid around the uterus. My hcg level was falling and I was rushed in for surgery and they found that there was a hole in one of my tubes and my abdomen was full of blood. They washed me out and saved the tube. The doctor told me after the surgery that I had a lot of scarring in my tubes and she thought that if I tried to get pregnant again that it would result in a tubal pregnancy. What should I do? Should I just forget about getting pregnant?
February 22nd, 2010 at 4:58 pm
Jennifer – Your information indicates that you had a ruptured tubal pregnancy. With scarring of your fallopian tubes, IVF would be the best option if you want to become pregnant again.
April 6th, 2010 at 6:17 pm
[...] couldn’t promise. He gave us some instructions and paperwork and we were sent to the hospital.Ectopic Pregnancy After Tubal Reversal.We arrived at the hospital and were rushed through admissions, and into the [...]
April 22nd, 2010 at 8:25 am
[...] but we were also very aware the likelihood of it being a miscarriage – or even worse an ectopic pregnancy.Pregnancy Risks After Tubal Reversal After work, I went to the ER and we spent all of New Years Eve [...]
September 12th, 2010 at 9:01 pm
I had my TL done in 1996 when I was just barely 26yrs old, and my doctor NEVER told me about all of the horrible things that can come from this procedure…and to make matters even worse when I went back 2 weeks later for severe pain in my side, he had FORGOTTEN he had done the tubal ligation and thought I was there for a post delivery check up. I had these pains for 13 years..been in and out of the dr’s office and the ER’s only being told “surgical adhesions” were the cause of my problems. Then about 4 months ago, the pains stopped. Last month I started gaining weight, was exhausted, my ankles kept swelling, then nausea. I didn’t think it was possible, but the pregnancy test was positive…which my dr thinks was a chemical pregnancy. Can this happen again or is this just a fluke that won’t ever happen again?
September 12th, 2010 at 9:05 pm
Tammy
Any pregnancy after tubal ligation is concerning for an abnormal opening in the tube. This can lead to an ectopic pregnancy. If you were every to have another positive pregnancy test again then you should see a medical professional right away. It is possible this can reoccur.
September 26th, 2010 at 10:33 am
I am worried I had a tubal reversal in 2009 and I have had two ectopic pregnancy I am 36 and I so want to have another baby. My first was on my left side and the last was on my right side. Dose this mean both sides are blocked? The doctor that did my surgery is no help I am looking for answers please help me.
September 26th, 2010 at 12:16 pm
Alicia
You should have a HSG x-ray to evaluate your tubes. Your reversal doctor will have to discuss the results with you.
November 28th, 2011 at 11:53 am
Is there a time frame to wait after having a tubal reversal to become pregnant to reduce the chances of an ectopic pregnancy?
November 28th, 2011 at 12:30 pm
Jenny – There is no arbitrary period that you need to wait after tubal reversal to reduce the chances of an ectopic pregnancy.
January 11th, 2012 at 10:41 pm
I followed your rules perfectly but it doesn’t matter because all of the Physicians I saw had the wrong answers to everything.
My first HCG count was 750. Two days later it was 1500. I started spotting the next day. Was in Vegas and went to the ER. The doctor there sent me for an abdominal ultrasound which showed no baby. Then the vaginal ultrasound showed no baby but my HCG count was 2300. Dr said that the problem is that people go off of the date of a girls last period which I had tracked along with ovulation. She said I may not be the six weeks that the chart said and may only be 4 weeks. She said at 4 wks, the ultrasound machines would not even show a sac. She said the spotting was because of sex which we said we hadn’t had.
Then got home to Oklahoma City and went to the ER because I was in so much pain that I couldn’t do anything but scream and cry. 7 doctors were by my side because they couldn’t keep my blood pressure stable it was 70/40 and I had 3 IVs running. They told me flat out that they thought I was going to die. Since there was only one OBGYN Surgeon on call, we had to wait til she got there. I cried and told the doctors that I didn’t want to die. They said that they understand and would want to go to a different hospital also but they were afraid that I would die on route if I didn’t have the ER care that I needed. They did an abdominal ultrasound and vaginal ultrasound and neither showed a baby. I did have an HCG of 3200. I told them that I must have an ectopic pregnancy. I asked for the drug that aborts the baby and they laughed and said that is not possible with tubal pregnancies. They said, once the baby attaches to the tube that the tube must be removed. I’m certain they are wrong. They finally decided to believe because of my blood pressure and they were giving me enough morphine to take down an elephant and I was still screaming and I mean SCREAMING.
Well, the OBGYN showed up 6 hours later. She tried to get me to sign a consent for a hysterectomy which I refused. Then she tried to get me to sign a consent to remove one ovary and the tube if needed. I refused on the ovary. I was rushed into surgery and the surgeon removed my right fallopian tube. I was given a c-section type surgery and am still in recovery. (btw she butchered my beautiful scar line that Dr. Berger did) It’s been 6 wks. So how can this be prevented again? It can’t.
I couldn’t find an OBGYN that would agree to see patients before 10 weeks. They said it is because of the high risk of miscarriages. Instead of waiting, I decided to go to a family urgent care clinic for my counts.
The only thing I can say is be prepared for the worst and hope for the best. I can tell you that I am now having some type of panic problems. I keep reliving the pain and horrible experience over and over again. I have a hard time trying to forget what happened. The pain of an ectopic pregnancy is indescribable. I’m not trying to scare you. I only want you to find a way to prepare yourself.
If the doctor does not see the baby, then maybe you may consider aborting. However, if the doctor says that you may only be 4 wks when your chart says 6 wks, and they can’t see the baby, you may need to get another ultrasound quick.
Just one more thing. Yes, I know I can probably get pregnant on the left side but now my chances are only every other month which is now going to take twice as long. Plus, I’m so scared about having the same thing happen again but I really want a baby.
My understanding is that my baby got caught in the scar tissue of the right fallopian tube. Is there not a way to prevent scar tissue on the tube? Or better yet, is there a test to see if I have scar tissue covering my left tube?
January 12th, 2012 at 4:39 pm
Janelle – I am distressed to learn about what happened. I cannot understand why some doctors do not follow our recommendations for early pregnancy monitoring since they can prevent the complication of a possible ruptured tubal pregnancy. You could have an HSG to assess your left tube. If you do have this done in the future, please instruct the radiologist to send your HSG images to us to review. An HSG would have to be ordered by your local physician.