Tubal Ligation Reversal Blog

IVF vs. Tubal Ligation Reversal

Women who want more children after tubal ligation must decide between two treatment options:  In-vitro fertilization (IVF) and tubal ligation reversal.

In-Vitro Fertilization (IVF)

This medical treatment involves controlling the woman’s natural cycle with hormone injections that stimulate the ovaries to produce a large number of eggs. The eggs are retrieved from the ovaries, combined with sperm in a laboratory and the fertilized eggs are placed inside the uterus. A single course or cycle of treatment takes three to eight weeks. The success rates are variable and depend on the reasons for infertility. In general, success rates per cycle are 10 to 30 percent.

Most IVF specialists advise patients to start the process by planning to undergo at least three cycles. The average cost of a cycle in the US is approximately $10,000 to $12,000, and can be as high as $20,000. Recently CNN and the NY Times have reported on the costs of in-vitro fertilization.

The most serious risk of IVF is ovarian hyperstimulation syndrome (OHSS). Ovarian hyperstimulation syndrome may be classified as mild, moderate or severe. The worst cases are associated with pregnancy since HCG (the pregnancy hormone) continues to stimulate the ovaries. Severe OHSS is a life threatening complication.  Despite careful monitoring, up to 33 percent of IVF treatments has been reported to be associated with mild forms of OHSS. Severe OHSS has been reported in three to eight percent of IVF cycles. Other risks of IVF are multiple gestations (30-50 percent) and ectopic pregnancy (three percent).

Tubal Ligation Reversal

This surgical treatment involves reattaching fallopian tubes that have previously undergone surgical separation (tubal occlusion or tubal ligation). The surgery time can range from one to five hours, and the average costs in the US can be $8,000 to $9,000, but can be as high as $25,000. Approximately 70 percent of patients who undergo tubal ligation reversal will become pregnant. Pregnancy rates for reversal depend on the patient’s age and the method of tubal ligation, and can range from 20 to 80 percent. The main risk of tubal ligation reversal is an increased risk of ectopic pregnancy (10 percent).

When to Choose IVF versus Tubal Reversal

IVF is a good treatment for couples who have unexplained infertility, severe sperm disorders and for women with severely damaged fallopian tubes from pelvic inflammatory disease (PID).

Tubal ligation reversal is a better treatment for women who have previously had a tubal ligation and who do not have any of the above indications for IVF.

Ligation Reversal Misinformation

Misinformation regarding tubal ligation reversal exists on the Internet. Most of this misinformation centers on the success of ligation reversal when compared to IVF, the cost and the risks of the surgical procedure.

Success Rates

The success rates of ligation reversal are related to the type of sterilization procedure a patient has undergone. At Chapel Hill Tubal Reversal Center, 69 percent of patients become pregnant after reversal of ligation and resection sterilizations. Clip and band sterilization procedures have excellent reversal results with 76 percent of patients becoming pregnant.

For IVF the success rates depend on the reason for infertility and can range from 10 to 50 percent. The average success of a single cycle is approximately 30 percent. The success rates of IVF decrease with maternal age over 35 years of age. After 40 to 42 years of age, IVF specialists will advise the use of donor eggs (eggs from another woman) to increase the chances of success. Many IVF specialists will attempt to increase the pregnancy rate of IVF by transferring several embryos into the uterus. This increases the chance of multiple gestations. Sometimes high order multiple gestations (triplets or more) will occur and these pregnancies can be very high-risk pregnancies.

Tubal ligation reversal has a higher chance of success when compared to a cycle of IVF by providing the couple with multiple opportunities to become pregnant and the ability to have more than one pregnancy without the need for hormonal control of the cycle.

Chapel Hill Tubal Reversal Center has success rates that are better than the 30 percent average success rates associated with an individual cycle of IVF.

Cost

Many sources quote tubal ligation reversal as high as $25,000. This is true if reversal ligation surgery is done in a hospital-based ambulatory care center or a hospital with an overnight stay. If a patient has a laparoscopic tubal ligation reversal or robotic assisted tubal ligation reversal, then they will pay much higher costs for surgery.

When performed as an outpatient procedure through a small abdominal incision and using microsurgical technique, ligation reversal surgery can be very affordable. Many patients are mislead to believe modern technology results in better success of ligation reversal; however, current medical literature does not support increased success rates for tubal ligation reversal when these surgeries are done laparoscopically or with robotic assistance. Success rates are similar with the use of these modern technologies when compared with abdominal incisions and microsurgical operative techniques. What is very clear is the use of these modern technologies dramatically increase the cost of reversal surgery.

The medical director of Chapel Hill Tubal Reversal Center, Dr. Gary Berger, has perfected a mini-laparotomy approach (mini-abdominal incision). He has continually refined this technique over the last twenty years. It allows easy access to the fallopian tubes and a quick operation. This minimizes the amount of time a patient spends under anesthesia. The decreased anesthetic time results in faster postoperative recovery and reduces the cost and risk of being under an anesthetic. Many hospitals charge patients for anesthesia by the minute and the longer a surgery, the higher the cost. This is true even if the surgery is done in a hospital ambulatory care center. The longer a patient is exposed to anesthesia, the more difficult and longer it takes to recover from the medication effects.

Chapel Hill Tubal Reversal Center is a free standing health care facility that is licensed by the State of North Carolina as a surgical center and has been accredited by the Joint Commission on Hospital Accreditation. Our free standing center is dedicated only to ligation reversal. We do not have to charge for anesthesia by the minute to help subsidize the services of other patients. To help patients who have ligation reversal at our center have a good postoperative period, patients stay at a local hotel and are seen the day after surgery by one of our tubal reversal nurses. Mini-laparotomy surgery is extremely safe with minimal postoperative discomfort and therefore, does not require an unnecessary, overnight hospital stay. A hotel stay is far cheaper than a hospital admission. As a result, we are able to offer ligation reversal for $5,900.

Risk of Tubal Reversal Surgery

Tubal reversal surgery is extremely safe in the appropriate patient. Patients who are not morbidly obese and who do not have severe heart, lung or vascular disease are excellent candidates for outpatient reversal surgery. There is a 10 percent risk of ectopic surgery after ligation reversal; however, with close follow-up of an early pregnancy, this risk can be appropriately managed to avoid the complication of tubal rupture.

We have had excellent operative results with few adverse outcomes in our reversal patients. We advise close follow-up care of our patients. Most suspected ectopic pregnancies are diagnosed early and treated with medical management to prevent complications.

Our Goal

At Chapel Hill Tubal Reversal Center, we are tubal ligation reversal experts dedicated to providing safe and low cost tubal ligation reversal. By keeping the cost low and focusing only on tubal ligation reversal, we make reversing a tubal ligation available to women who would be unable to afford the high cost of in-vitro fertilization or tubal reversal in the hospital setting.

Be Sociable, Share!

64 thoughts on “IVF vs. Tubal Ligation Reversal

  1. Dr. Monteith Post author

    Faith
    You can not easily tell the sex of the baby at the start of IVF.
    Tubal reversal is better and more affordable than IVF. Tubal reversal costs $5900 at our center and the average success is 70%. IVF costs around $10,000 to $12,000 and the success per cycle is 35-40%.

  2. Dr. Monteith Post author

    Faith
    Tubal reversal is better and more affordable than IVF. Tubal reversal costs $5900 at our center and the average success is 70%. IVF costs around $10,000 to $12,000 and the success per cycle is 35-40%. You can not easily tell the sex of the baby at the start of IVF.

  3. Faith Norman

    I had my tubes tied in 2007 during a C-Section when I was having my daughter. I think he said he done a tubaligation, but I’m not sure what procedure he used. All I know after I healed my ovaries, and deep in my belly under my c-section. I have periods for 12 days at a time now. I used to be regular. When My husband & I are intimate sometimes I start my period right after & then I quit bleeding over night. It causes alot of problems between my husband & I because I’m bleeding most of the time. I was also diagnosed with low Iron, I’m a little anemic. My new Husband doesn’t have any children & I would love to make a baby with him. Hopefully a boy because his Dad has no one to carry on the family name. When you do IVF can you tell whether it’s a boy or girl?
    THANK YOU, Faith Norman

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Powered by sweetCaptcha